Essential soul albums: a guide to the greatest music ever made

Soul music emerged from the intersection of gospel and rhythm and blues in the late 1950s and early 1960s, and in the two decades that followed it produced some of the most extraordinary, emotionally powerful recorded music in human history. The best soul records deal in raw feeling, communal experience, and the full range of human emotion from joy to grief, desire to dignity. They were made by artists who had experienced discrimination and hardship and who channelled those experiences into music of breathtaking beauty and power.

Building a collection of essential soul albums on vinyl is one of the most rewarding things a music lover can do. The music is timeless, the recordings are excellent, and the secondhand market makes it accessible at every budget level.

The foundations: Motown, Stax, and Atlantic

Any serious engagement with soul music has to begin with the three great labels that defined its classic period. Motown, founded by Berry Gordy in Detroit in 1959, produced a polished, pop-influenced version of soul designed to cross racial boundaries and reach the widest possible audience. The results were extraordinary: Marvin Gaye, Stevie Wonder, The Temptations, The Miracles, The Four Tops, Martha and the Vandellas, all of them recording music of impeccable craft and emotional depth.

Marvin Gaye's What's Going On from 1971 is often cited as the greatest soul album ever made, and it is difficult to argue with that assessment. A continuous suite of songs dealing with Vietnam, drug addiction, and the environment, it demonstrated that soul music could be an art form capable of engaging with the most pressing social issues of the day while remaining radiantly beautiful. It is essential.

Stax Records from Memphis operated at a very different register. Where Motown was polished and orchestrated, Stax was raw, direct and rooted in Southern gospel and blues. Otis Redding, Isaac Hayes, Sam and Dave, Wilson Pickett, Booker T and the MGs, all recorded for Stax or its sister label Volt, and the results were some of the most intensely physical recordings in the soul canon. Otis Redding's Otis Blue from 1965 is perhaps the finest distillation of the Stax sound, a record of almost unbearable emotional intensity.

Atlantic Records in New York was the third great pillar of classic soul, home to Aretha Franklin, Ray Charles, Wilson Pickett and many others. Aretha Franklin's I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You from 1967 is the essential Atlantic soul album, a record on which Franklin's voice is used with such devastating skill and emotional truth that it remains unmatched fifty years later.

Deep soul and southern soul

Beyond the major labels, a parallel world of deep soul and southern soul was being recorded throughout the sixties and seventies on smaller regional labels, particularly in Alabama, Mississippi and Tennessee. This music is rawer, more gospel-rooted, and often more emotionally intense than the Motown and early Stax material.

Labels like Fame, Muscle Shoals Sound, and Goldwax produced records of extraordinary quality that were often only locally distributed and are now among the most sought-after records in the world. James Carr, one of the great vocal stylists of the era, recorded for Goldwax and his records are both devastatingly moving and, in good original pressing condition, very expensive. The You Got My Mind Messed Up album from 1966 is a starting point.

Clarence Carter, O.V. Wright, and Bobby Bland all recorded deep soul material of the highest order. These are artists whose work is less well-known than the Motown and Atlantic stars but who, for many serious collectors, represent the genre at its absolute peak.

Sixties girl groups and the wall of sound

Phil Spector's wall of sound production technique transformed soul and pop in the early sixties, creating a dense, orchestrated sonic landscape that was as radical as anything happening in contemporary music. The records he made with The Ronettes, The Crystals, and Darlene Love are extraordinary sonic achievements as well as great pop music.

Beyond Spector, the broader world of sixties girl group music from labels like Red Bird, Scepter, Wand and many others contains some of the most joyful and emotionally direct recordings of the era. The Shirelles, The Chiffons, The Shangri-Las, all made records that balance teenage experience with musical sophistication in a way that remains completely fresh. Original pressings are abundant and relatively affordable in the secondhand market.

Seventies soul and its offshoots

As the seventies progressed, soul music evolved in several directions simultaneously. Funk, pioneered by James Brown and developed by Parliament-Funkadelic, Sly and the Family Stone, and many others, foregrounded rhythm over melody and produced a harder, more percussive sound. Al Green, recording for Hi Records in Memphis, took soul in a more intimate and spiritual direction, producing a run of albums in the early seventies, Let's Stay Together, I'm Still in Love with You, Call Me, that represent one of the most consistently excellent bodies of work in the entire genre.

Philly soul, developed by Kenny Gamble and Leon Huff at Philadelphia International Records, offered a smoother, more orchestrated sound that bridged soul and the emerging disco movement. Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes, The O'Jays, and Billy Paul all recorded for the label, and the quality of the recordings is exceptional.

Discover soul on vinyl with Makes Noise

Soul music rewards the vinyl format more than almost any other genre. The warmth and presence of a well-pressed soul record played on a good turntable is something genuinely special. Makes Noise sends a curated mystery box of at least four secondhand recordings every month to soul subscribers, always including at least one vinyl record, sourced from a range of places, including charity shops. For £22.22 a month delivered, it is the most pleasurable way to build a soul collection. Subscribe at makesnoise.com.

Keep reading

If you want to hear more, explore our soul vinyl subscription.

Subscribe to the mystery music box