Crate digging: a beginner's guide to finding great vinyl

There is a very particular feeling that comes from flicking through a crate of second-hand records and pulling out something you never expected to find. It might be an original pressing of an album you have been looking for, or a record by an artist you have never heard of whose cover art alone makes you want to take it home and play it. It might be something you already own but in a condition so much better than your copy that you cannot justify leaving it behind. Whatever it is, crate digging delivers a thrill that no streaming service or algorithmic playlist can replicate.

But for newcomers, the whole thing can feel faintly intimidating. Where do you go? How do you know what to look for? How do you avoid spending money on records that turn out to be worthless or unplayable? This guide will walk you through everything you need to know to start digging with confidence.

Where to go crate digging in the UK

The most obvious and accessible starting point is your local charity shops. Oxfam, Age UK, the British Heart Foundation, and many independent charity shops regularly stock vinyl donated by the public, usually at prices ranging from fifty pence to a few pounds per record. The quality and selection varies enormously, but that unpredictability is part of the appeal. In areas with older populations or wealthier demographics, charity shops often receive donations of genuinely valuable records from house clearances.

Record fairs are another excellent hunting ground. These events, held regularly in cities and towns across the UK, bring together dealers and private sellers offering everything from common chart releases to genuinely rare pressings. The prices are higher than charity shops but the selection is more curated and you are more likely to find specific things you are looking for. Record Store Day, held each April and September, brings extra stock and events to independent record shops across the country.

Flea markets, car boot sales and antique markets are also worth exploring. Prices can be very low, knowledge among sellers is often limited, and it is possible to find real gems among the dross. The key is to go early, go often, and develop the patience to look through everything rather than cherry-picking.

How to assess a record quickly

When you are working through a crate, speed is important. You cannot spend five minutes examining every single record or you will never cover enough ground. Develop a quick visual assessment routine. Look at the cover first for obvious damage, writing, or water stains. Pull the record out of its sleeve and hold it up to the light at an angle. Severe scratches, pressing defects, or deep groove damage will be visible. Light surface marks or scuffs are often less serious than they look and usually clean up well.

The condition of the sleeve is a reasonable proxy for how the record has been treated, though not a reliable one. A pristine cover with a badly played record is common, as is a battered sleeve protecting a very clean disc. Never judge entirely by the sleeve.

For classical records and jazz, the label is important. Original pressings of certain labels, Decca, Columbia, EMI, Parlophone, Blue Note, Prestige, are often significantly more valuable than later reissues. Learning to recognise original label designs is a rabbit hole that can consume years of pleasurable study.

What to look for as a beginner

When you are starting out, try not to get too caught up in rarity and value. The goal of crate digging is to find music you will actually enjoy listening to. Start with genres you already love and look for records you recognise. This gives you a frame of reference and helps you understand what a record in good condition should look and sound like.

As you gain confidence, start taking more risks on artists you do not recognise. A great cover design, an interesting label, or a curious title can be enough justification for spending a pound or two on an unknown record. Some of the best finds come from exactly this kind of instinctive grab.

Soul, jazz, and reggae records from the sixties and seventies are particularly rewarding hunting grounds for beginners. There was so much recorded in these genres during those decades that even the more common releases often contain extraordinary music. The secondary market is broad enough that affordable copies of genuinely great records are still relatively easy to find.

Electronic music, particularly from the eighties and nineties, is another productive area. Many synth-pop, new wave and early dance records were pressed in large quantities and are plentiful in charity shops and at record fairs, often at very low prices. Their sound translates particularly well to vinyl.

Cleaning and playing your finds

Always clean charity shop or second-hand records before playing them. Even records that look clean will have dust and debris in the grooves that can damage your stylus and produce surface noise. A basic clean with a microfibre cloth and a record cleaning solution before the first play is the minimum. For genuinely dirty records, a wet clean with a dedicated record cleaning solution and a soft brush is worth the extra effort.

Do not put a new find straight onto your turntable without checking the stylus tracking force is set correctly. Playing a damaged or very dirty record can dislodge debris that scratches both the record and the stylus. Patience at this stage protects your equipment and your collection.

Building a crate digger's toolkit

You do not need much to get started with crate digging, but a few tools make the process easier and more rewarding. A carbon fibre anti-static brush is essential for cleaning records before and after play. A basic record cleaning solution and a soft cloth handles the initial clean of second-hand finds. Protective polythene outer sleeves and new inner sleeves are worth buying in bulk to re-sleeve anything you bring home in poor packaging.

For serious diggers, a smartphone with the Discogs app installed is invaluable. You can scan a barcode or search an artist and title to find out immediately whether a record has any value, what original pressings look like, and what similar copies have recently sold for. This takes much of the guesswork out of pricing and helps you make faster, more confident decisions in the field.

The Makes Noise approach to music discovery

If you love the idea of crate digging but cannot always find the time, Makes Noise does the hunting for you. Every month we source secondhand vinyl, CDs and tapes from a range of places, including charity shops, curate boxes by genre, and deliver them to your door for £22.22 a month. Every box contains at least four recordings including at least one vinyl record, every piece is cleaned before packing, and you get the thrill of not knowing exactly what is coming until you open the box. Subscribe at makesnoise.com and let the discovery begin.

Keep reading

Before you head out, read our guide to buying second hand vinyl, and see how Record Store Day in the UK can turn a shop visit into an event.

Subscribe to the mystery music box