Buying second hand vinyl in the UK

Second hand vinyl is how most record collections get built. New pressings are lovely, but secondhand shops, fairs and online sellers hold decades of music at a range of prices, and the thrill of finding something unexpected is half the appeal. This guide to second hand vinyl in the UK explains where to look, how to check a record, and how to avoid paying too much.

If you would rather not do all the searching yourself, a monthly UK vinyl subscription from Makes Noise delivers four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box, picked in the genre you choose. More on that at the end.

Where to buy second hand vinyl

There is no single best place. Different sources suit different tastes and budgets, and most collectors use several.

Independent record shops

Independent shops are the best place to start. Staff know their stock, you can hold the record before you pay, and many will let you listen to a copy in the shop. Staff are also a useful source of recommendations, so do not be shy about asking what has come in recently. Prices depend on the shop and the record, so it is worth browsing a few. Our guide to crate digging explains how to work through a shop's racks without getting overwhelmed.

Charity shops, markets and fairs

Charity shops, car boot sales and markets can turn up bargains, but they are hit and miss, and condition varies widely. Record fairs are better organised: many dealers in one place, with stock sorted by genre, and plenty of people to ask for advice. Go early for the best choice, and late if you want to haggle.

Everywhere else

Look at house clearances, local selling groups and friends who are tidying up. Collections sold in bulk can include real finds among a lot of records you will not want, so only buy them if you can see the records first.

Buying second hand vinyl online

Buying second hand vinyl online gives you access to far more records than any shop, but you cannot hold the copy, so you rely on the seller's description. A few habits protect you.

  • Read the listing carefully, including the grade for both the record and the sleeve.
  • Look at the photos. Good sellers show the label, the sleeve and the playing surface.
  • Check the seller's feedback and returns policy before you pay.
  • Compare the postage cost to the price of the record, because it can change which seller is best value.

Marketplaces such as Discogs list second hand vinyl records from sellers around the world and let you see the grade, the pressing and the seller's history. Auction sites can be good for finding unusual copies, but they work best when you know what you are looking for. For a first purchase, a small order from a seller with a clear description is a sensible start.

How to check a record before you buy

If you can see the record, check it properly. A quick look takes a minute and can save you from a disappointment.

  • Slide the record out gently and hold it by the edges.
  • Tilt the surface under a light. Scratches show as lines, scuffs as hazy patches, and warps show when you look along the edge.
  • Check the label is intact and matches the sleeve.
  • Look at the sleeve for splits, writing, water marks and ring wear.
  • If the shop allows it, ask to hear a track, especially on a record you are paying more for.

Check the contents too. Sleeves and records do not always match, so confirm that the label on the disc is the one that belongs in that cover. A sleeve with the wrong record inside is a common disappointment, especially with records that have been through several owners.

Marks you can see are not always marks you can hear, and a clean-looking record can still be noisy. A record that looks rough may still play well after a proper clean, so it is worth reading our guide on how to clean vinyl records before you give up on a dusty copy. A record with a deep scratch or a bad warp is another matter.

Understanding grading

Sellers describe condition using a grading scale. The most common one runs from Mint at the top down through Near Mint, Very Good Plus, Very Good, Good and Fair or Poor. The record and the sleeve are graded separately, so a listing may show, for example, a Very Good Plus record in a Very Good sleeve.

In general, Near Mint means the record looks almost new and plays very well. Very Good Plus is a lightly played copy with minor marks that should not spoil the listening. Very Good means audible wear is likely, such as some crackle. Anything below that is best bought as a stopgap or for a record you cannot find elsewhere.

Always ask for both grades, and be wary of a listing that only describes one. A superb record in a damaged sleeve may be a bargain if you only want to listen, but a poor deal if you wanted to display the cover.

Grading is a judgement, and sellers vary in how strict they are. A cautious seller may describe a record more harshly than an optimistic one. Photos, comments and the seller's feedback help you work out how reliable a grade is.

Getting a fair price

The right price for a record depends on the title, the pressing and the condition. Two copies of the same album can have very different values.

  • Compare recent sale prices for the same edition, not just asking prices. Marketplaces show what records have actually sold for.
  • Adjust for condition. A cleaner copy is worth more than a worn one of the same record.
  • Do not pay a premium until you know whether the record is genuinely scarce. Many records that look old are common.
  • Be willing to walk away. If the price does not feel right, another copy will usually turn up.
  • Ask about bundles. Many sellers will offer a better price if you take several records, and that is a good way to try a genre you are curious about.

If you are curious about why some records are worth more than others, our guide to which vinyl records are worth money explains what affects value. For a wider picture of how to build a collection sensibly, see our guide to how to start a record collection.

Second hand vinyl delivered every month

If the idea of searching shops and sites sounds like hard work, a subscription takes the hunting out of it. With Makes Noise, you get four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box, every month. Every record is cleaned before packing. It costs £22.22 a month.

You choose from eight genres: rock, soul, jazz, electronic, pop, classical, hip hop and country. Boxes are dispatched in the first week of each month, and delivery within the UK takes up to 14 days from dispatch. It is UK delivery only.

It will not replace the pleasure of a day in the racks, but it is a good way to keep new music arriving between trips.

Next step

If you want the secondhand finds without the legwork, try a monthly vinyl subscription and see what turns up.

Subscribe to the mystery music box