Gifts for vinyl lovers

Buying gifts for vinyl lovers is easier than it looks, as long as you remember one thing: they already know what they want to hear, and what they want most is to be surprised by something they would never have found alone. This guide covers gifts for vinyl lovers at every budget, from a good cleaning brush to records they have never heard of, with honest advice on what to skip.

If you only have a minute, the safest gift is the one that keeps on giving. A vinyl subscription gift sends a new batch of secondhand records through the door every month, so it works for the person who owns hundreds of records and for the person who has just bought their first player. More on that below, with the practical details.

Records they don't already own

The classic gift is a record, and the classic mistake is a record they already have. Before you buy anything, spend ten minutes finding out what is on their shelves. Look at the spines next time you visit, or ask a friend or partner to take a photo of the collection. Many collectors also keep a wantlist on a site such as Discogs, and some will happily share it if you ask.

Choosing records as gifts for vinyl lovers

The best records to give are the ones sitting just outside what someone already owns. If their shelves are full of one artist, look at the band that artist always talks about. If they love a particular label or scene, try something from the same era by a name they may have missed. A reissue of a favourite album in a new pressing can also work, provided you are sure they do not already own that version.

Three safe approaches:

  • A record by an artist they love that you have checked they do not own.
  • A record from a genre they enjoy but rarely buy, such as a jazz or soul classic for a rock fan.
  • A gift voucher for an independent record shop, so they can browse the racks themselves.

If you are shopping for a serious collector, our guide to gifts for record collectors goes further into how to find out what a collector wants.

Accessories every collector uses

Accessories are the gift that people rarely buy for themselves and always end up using. A good cleaning routine protects records and makes them sound better, so a cleaning kit is almost always welcome. A carbon fibre record brush is a simple, inexpensive place to start, and a soft stylus brush helps keep the needle clean. Our guide on how to clean vinyl records explains what each tool does, so you can choose with confidence.

Other accessories that rarely go to waste:

  • Fresh inner sleeves, ideally anti-static, to replace the paper sleeves records often come in.
  • Clear outer sleeves to protect the cover from scuffs and spills.
  • A replacement slipmat, if you know the one on their turntable is worn.
  • A stylus gauge or a small spirit level for someone who likes to fine-tune their setup.

For a longer shopping list, see our guide to vinyl accessories, which separates the essentials from the nice-to-have items.

Storage and display

A growing collection needs somewhere to live. Records are heavy and should be stored upright, not stacked flat, so shelving built for 12-inch records is a thoughtful gift. Look for units that are sturdy enough for the weight and deep enough for the sleeves. A set of cube shelves, a dedicated record crate or a low unit that doubles as a turntable stand all suit different homes.

Some people like to display a favourite sleeve while it plays. A wall-mounted sleeve display, or a small frame designed for album covers, lets them show off the artwork they love. If you want to give something that protects the collection as well as showing it off, read our advice on how to store vinyl records first, so you know what makes good storage.

Gifts for vinyl lovers with a new record player

A new record player is a lovely thing to receive, and new owners usually need a few extras to get going. These record player gifts tend to land well, because they fill the gaps that people only notice after the first week.

Record player gifts for beginners

Think about what stops someone enjoying their first records. A cleaning kit and a pack of inner sleeves keep the first records in good shape. A few first records in a genre they love save them from the hunt. If their player does not have built-in speakers, a pair of suitable speakers or a small amplifier may be the most useful present of all, although it pays to check what their player needs before you buy. Our guide to the best budget turntable in the UK explains what to look for in a starter player, which is useful background if you are not sure what they own.

A vinyl subscription as a gift

A subscription is the one gift on this list that solves the problem of what to buy for every month, not just once. With Makes Noise, each box contains four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box. Every record is cleaned before packing. The gift version is £66.66 for three months as a one-off payment, with no auto-renewal, so there is nothing for the recipient to cancel.

Here is how it works in practice. You choose the genre, from rock, soul, jazz, electronic, pop, classical, hip hop or country, and add the recipient's name and UK address. If you like, you add a short message, which goes in their welcome email. They are emailed as soon as you have paid. Boxes are dispatched in the first week of the month, and delivery within the UK takes up to 14 days from dispatch. It is UK delivery only.

The records are chosen by people who dig through real shops, which is the point: neither you nor the recipient knows exactly what is coming. If you are weighing it up against a regular monthly plan, our monthly vinyl subscription page covers that. For the gift itself, the three-month option is the simplest way to say you want them to keep discovering music.

What to avoid buying

A few gifts disappoint more often than they delight:

  • A turntable for someone who already has one. Unless you know their player is on its last legs, ask first.
  • Very cheap all-in-one players with no way to adjust the tracking weight. Some can be hard on records, so a better player is usually worth the extra spend.
  • Records bought only because they are famous. Collectors often own the famous ones already.
  • Accessories that do not fit what they own, such as a stylus for a cartridge you have not checked.
  • Anything you cannot exchange. If you are unsure, ask the shop about its returns policy before you pay.

If in doubt, a gift that leaves the choosing to them, such as a voucher or a subscription, beats a guess. For wider ideas beyond vinyl, see our guide to gifts for music lovers.

Questions people ask

What do you buy someone who has everything on vinyl?

Something they cannot easily buy for themselves: a surprise. A mystery subscription, a record from a label or scene they have not explored, or a tool that improves how they play and care for their collection all work well.

Is a vinyl subscription a good gift?

It suits people who enjoy discovery, because they do not know what will arrive. The Makes Noise gift is £66.66 for three months with no auto-renewal, and each box has four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box.

Do they need a record player for the box?

They need a record player to play the vinyl. Some subscribers also receive cassettes, so a tape player is useful if you tick that option when you order.

Can I send the gift outside the UK?

No. Delivery is to UK addresses only.

When will the first box arrive?

Boxes are dispatched in the first week of each month, and delivery within the UK takes up to 14 days from dispatch.

Next step

If you would like the gift to arrive without you having to choose a record, give a vinyl subscription and let someone else do the digging.

Subscribe to the mystery music box