Gifts for record collectors
Buying gifts for record collectors is a different problem from buying for someone who simply likes vinyl. A serious collector knows exactly what they own, knows what is missing, and has opinions about pressings. This guide to gifts for record collectors shows how to find out what they want, what to buy when you cannot, and what to avoid.
If you cannot find out what is missing from their shelves, do not guess. A vinyl subscription gift hands the choosing to people who dig through record shops for a living, and collectors tend to enjoy the surprise of something they would never have picked. For wider gift ideas aimed at general vinyl fans, see our guide to gifts for vinyl lovers.
Find out what they collect first
Collectors are specific. One person collects every release by a single band, another collects a label, a scene or a decade, and a third buys anything with a particular producer. Before you buy, work out which kind of collector you are shopping for.
Questions that help when choosing gifts for record collectors
- What do they play most often, and what has been on the turntable lately?
- Do they collect by artist, label, genre, decade or pressing?
- Do they keep a wantlist, and would they share it?
- Do they care about first pressings, or do any decent copy of the album do?
- Do they buy new, secondhand, or both?
Take a look at how the collection is organised, too. Records sorted by label, by year or by artist tell you what the owner cares about, and gaps in a sequence hint at what they are chasing. A shelf that is alphabetical by artist usually belongs to someone who buys by artist, while a shelf full of one label's distinctive spines belongs to a completist.
If you are not close enough to ask directly, a mutual friend or a partner can usually tell you. Many collectors also love talking about what they are hunting for, so a casual question at the right moment can give you everything you need.
Records they won't find themselves
The most valuable record to give a collector is one they could not easily have bought: a copy they have been searching for, or a record from a corner of music they had not explored.
If you know they are hunting for a specific title, do a little research before you spend. Condition matters a great deal to collectors, and our guide on which vinyl records are worth money explains what affects value, such as pressing and condition, so you can judge a copy properly. Never pay a high price for a record without checking recent sale prices for that exact edition.
If you do not know what they need, aim for something related to their taste but adjacent to it: a band from the same scene, an album the artist cited as an influence, or a compilation from a label they love. Serious collectors often enjoy following a thread.
Gifts for record collectors who want better kit
Collectors tend to look after their records, so good kit is usually welcome, and often worth more than another album. Here are the types of gift that suit someone with a large collection.
- A record cleaning machine or a good cleaning kit, if they do not already have one.
- Archival inner sleeves and outer sleeves, bought in quantity, since collectors go through them.
- Sturdy shelving or crates built for the weight of 12-inch records.
- A stylus replacement, if you know their cartridge and want to be thoughtful.
If the collection is growing faster than the shelves, read our advice on how to store vinyl records before you buy storage. Records should be kept upright, away from heat and damp, and a gift that helps with that protects the whole collection.
Books about records and record shops
Collectors love to read about the world they live in. A good book about records, record shops or the people who make them is a safe and personal choice. A classic is the novel High Fidelity by Nick Hornby, which is set around a record shop, though many collectors will have read it already.
Books also help with the part of collecting that is about knowledge. Collectors enjoy learning which pressing is which, who played on a record, and why a particular label mattered. A well-researched book gives them a new way to enjoy records they already own, which is a rare thing for a gift to achieve.
Other options include histories of a label or genre, biographies of artists they admire, and guides to pressings for a particular scene. If you are not sure what they have read, a voucher for a bookshop works, but a book chosen for a specific interest shows more care. Our guide to how to start a record collection is useful if you are buying for a beginner who is just developing the habit.
A mystery box for the collector who has everything
Some collectors really do have everything on their wantlist, and for them the right gift is the unexpected. A mystery box turns the usual process around: instead of hunting, they open a package and find out what has been chosen for them.
A Makes Noise gift is £66.66 for three months, paid once, with no auto-renewal. Each box has four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box. You choose the genre, from rock, soul, jazz, electronic, pop, classical, hip hop or country, and add the recipient's UK address and a message if you like. They are emailed as soon as you have paid.
Boxes are dispatched in the first week of the month, and delivery within the UK takes up to 14 days from dispatch. It is UK delivery only. For a collector who enjoys the thrill of the crate, it recreates some of that excitement at home. If you want to share a day of digging as well, our guide to crate digging tips helps you plan a trip together.
For other ways to show you have thought about someone's taste, our guide to gifts for music lovers covers records, tapes and experiences.
Questions people ask
What do you buy a record collector who has everything?
Something outside their normal habits: a mystery box, a record from a genre they have not explored, an experience such as a day at a record fair, or good kit to protect what they own.
Is it a mistake to buy a collector a record?
Only if you do not check. Ask what they collect, look for their wantlist, and avoid buying an edition they already own. If in doubt, choose a gift that lets them choose.
What kit do collectors always need?
Inner and outer sleeves, a cleaning brush or machine, a stylus cleaner and good storage. These are used all the time, and many collectors never feel they have enough.
Are secondhand records a good gift?
Yes, if they are in good condition and chosen with care. Many collectors prefer secondhand records, because they are how most of a collection gets built.
How much should I spend on a gift for a record collector?
As much as suits your budget. Collectors value thought more than price, and a modest gift that fits their collection will land better than an expensive one that does not.
Can a record subscription be a gift for a serious collector?
Yes. Makes Noise gives a three-month gift for £66.66, with no auto-renewal, with each box containing four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box.
Next step
If you want to give a collector the pleasure of the unexpected, give a vinyl subscription and let the crate diggers choose.