Which vinyl records are worth money?

Everyone has heard the story of a dusty box in the loft that turned out to hold a small fortune. The reality is more modest, but it is true that some vinyl records are worth money, and it is worth knowing which ones before you take a stack to the charity shop. This guide explains which vinyl records worth money have in common, how to check, and what to avoid.

We do not quote values for particular records here, because prices change and condition matters so much. Instead, the guide shows you how to find real prices for your own copies. If you want to sell once you know the value, our guide on how to sell vinyl records covers the next step, and if you would rather spend your time listening than valuing, a monthly vinyl subscription sends four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box, picked in your genre.

What makes a record valuable

Value comes from a mix of rarity, demand and condition. A record can be rare and worth little if nobody wants it, and a record can be popular and worth little if there are millions of copies. The ones that fetch real money usually combine all three.

Old vinyl records worth money: the main factors

  • **Rarity:** Records pressed in small numbers, or that have become hard to find, tend to be worth more.
  • **Demand:** The artist, the album and the scene must be wanted by collectors. A scarce record by an unknown act is usually not valuable.
  • **Pressing:** The particular edition matters. A first pressing may be worth more than a later reissue of the same album.
  • **Condition:** The record and the sleeve both count, and a copy in excellent condition can be worth many times a worn one.
  • **Completeness:** Original inserts, posters, lyric sheets and obi strips, which are paper bands found on Japanese pressings, can add to the value.
  • **Format and edition:** Limited editions, coloured vinyl, picture discs, test pressings and signed copies are sought after, but only if the demand is there.
  • **Sealed copies:** An unopened record in its original shrink wrap can be worth more than an opened one, though it depends on the title.

Age on its own is not the point. A record from the 1950s is not valuable just because it is old, and a modern limited release can be worth more than a much older album. What matters is how many people want a copy and how few are available.

How to spot a first pressing

A first pressing is the earliest version of a record released to the public. Collectors often prefer it, because it is closest to the original release, and some pressings are known for particular sound qualities. It is not always the most valuable edition, but it is a good place to start looking.

Here is how to work out which pressing you have.

  • **Check the label:** The design, colours and wording on the centre label change between pressings. Compare yours with photos of known editions.
  • **Read the catalogue number:** Look on the label and the sleeve. The number identifies the release, and it is the key to finding the right listing.
  • **Look in the run-out groove:** This is the smooth area near the label, where numbers and letters are often scratched or stamped into the vinyl. These matrix numbers help identify the pressing.
  • **Note the country and year:** Printed on the label or the back of the sleeve. A record pressed in one country can differ from a copy pressed elsewhere.
  • **Examine the sleeve:** Printing details, the artwork, the credits and the barcode, or absence of one, all vary between editions.

Compare what you find with database listings for the same release, which often describe each pressing in detail. If there are several versions, the differences are usually small, so match as many details as you can. A guess is not good enough when the difference between two pressings can be large.

Condition and grading

Condition is the biggest variable you control. Two copies of the same pressing can sell for very different amounts, depending on how well they have been looked after.

Sellers grade the record and the sleeve separately, using a scale that runs from Mint, through Near Mint, Very Good Plus and Very Good, down to Good, Fair and Poor. Near Mint means almost like new, and Very Good Plus has only light signs of play. As you move down the scale, value falls, often quickly.

To grade a record yourself:

  • Hold it under a good light and tilt it to see scratches and scuffs.
  • Look along the edge for warping.
  • Check the label for writing or tears.
  • Inspect the sleeve for splits, stains, writing and ring wear.
  • If you can, play it and listen for crackle, jumps and noise.

Be honest, and err on the side of caution. If you are not sure, assume the lower grade. A clean record is easier to judge, so see our advice on how to store vinyl records to keep your best copies in good shape, since poor storage is one of the quickest ways to lose value.

How to check what your records are worth

Do not rely on a guess, a friend's memory or an old price guide. Check actual sales.

1. Identify the exact edition, using the catalogue number, the label and the run-out markings. 2. Search for that edition on a record marketplace such as Discogs, which keeps a database of releases and shows what copies have sold for. 3. Look at completed sales, not asking prices. Anyone can ask for a high price, but a sale shows what a buyer paid. 4. Match the condition. Compare your copy with sold copies in the same grade, because the price depends heavily on it. 5. Check several sales. A single high or low price can be unusual, and a spread of results gives a better picture. 6. Be sceptical about unusual claims. If a listing seems too good to be true, look for the detail that explains it.

If you are unsure, ask a specialist dealer, or visit a record fair and show your records to a few sellers. Their offers will be lower than a private sale, because they need to resell at a profit, but they will tell you quickly whether the record has value. Our guide to buying second hand vinyl explains how buyers think about price, which helps when you are on the other side of the deal.

Vinyl records worth money and those that are not

It is just as useful to know what is common. These types of record rarely sell for much, although there are always exceptions.

  • Mass-produced albums that sold in huge numbers, because there are plenty of copies around.
  • Greatest hits and budget compilations, unless they are unusual editions.
  • Records in poor condition, with deep scratches, warps or damaged sleeves.
  • Common reissues of albums that have been pressed many times.
  • Records with water damage, mould or heavy writing on the cover.

That does not mean they are worthless to listen to. A common album in so-so condition can still sound wonderful, and many of the best records in anyone's collection are inexpensive. If a record has value to you, keep it. Value in money and value in enjoyment are very different things.

What to do next

Once you know what you have, decide what you want to do with it. If a few records turn out to be worth money, you have options.

  • Keep them, and store them well, in sleeves, upright and away from heat and damp.
  • Sell the valuable ones through a marketplace, a specialist shop or a record fair.
  • Sell or donate the rest, or pass them to someone who will enjoy them.
  • Use any money to buy records you want to play.

Take your time. A rushed sale rarely gets the best price, and a record you sell cheaply cannot be bought back. If you plan to sell, our guide on how to sell vinyl records explains grading, listing and posting step by step.

Next step

If you would rather spend your time listening than valuing, a UK vinyl subscription sends four secondhand recordings, which can be vinyl, CDs or cassettes, with at least one vinyl record in every box, picked in your genre.

Subscribe to the mystery music box